Close your eyes, think of the most memorable editions of the Belmont Stakes of the past 50 or so years, and what do you see? Perhaps Secretariat moving like a machine. Affirmed and Alydar battling with nothing but a head separating them for a mile.

To many, the 2025 Belmont Stakes will just be a battle between Kentucky Derby and Preakness Stakes winners Sovereignty and Journalism. However, a notable horse racing insider suggested this week, one specific competitor is a serious threat to beat both thoroughbreds on Saturday.

For McCarthy, the 54-year-old former assistant to Todd Pletcher, the Preakness was his second career Triple Crown triumph. He sent Rombauer to the winner’s circle in the 2021 Preakness. Rombauer then cashed a show ticket in the Belmont Stakes.